6 min
Sixty votes in the Senate
See why the Senate often needs 60 votes and how both chambers agree on one text.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Compare how the House and the Senate move a bill to a vote
- Explain what a filibuster is and how cloture ends one
- Describe how the House and Senate settle on one text
In the House, H.R. 4127 passed with a simple majority of those voting, 287 to 133. Now it's in the Senate, and everyone tells Maya the number is 60. Nothing in the Constitution says 60. So where does it come from?
Maya meets Priya, who works for a senator from the same state. First the bill goes to a Senate committee, which holds its own markup and approves it. Then Priya's senator asks the Majority Leader, who decides what the Senate takes up, to bring H.R. 4127 to the floor. The Majority Leader is the Senate's counterpart to the Speaker. She explains that the Senate has no committee that limits debate on each bill, the way the House Rules Committee does. Debate ends when every senator agrees to end it, or when the Senate votes to end it. So a determined group of senators can hold a bill up.
- Who sets the terms of debate? House: a rule from the Rules Committee. Senate: unanimous agreement, or a cloture vote.
- Can a minority stall a bill by talking? House: no, debate time is fixed. Senate: yes, that's a filibuster.
- Votes to pass? House: a majority of those voting. Senate: a majority of those voting, once debate ends.
- A tied vote: in the House, the bill fails. In the Senate, the Vice President can break the tie.
- Where must tax bills start? In the House. The Senate can still amend them.
Predict, then reveal
You're Priya. Some senators refuse to end debate on H.R. 4127. You have 55 senators who support the bill. Is 55 enough to end debate and get to a vote?
Priya counts. The 55 senators of the majority party support the bill. Eight more are on the fence, worried about the cost of printing new labels. Her senator offers an amendment giving companies two years to switch labels instead of one, and the Senate adopts it. Six of the eight agree to end debate. Cloture passes 61 to 39.
Predict, then reveal
Debate is over. You're Maya, watching from the gallery. Does the bill need another 60 votes to pass, or fewer?
So… our version gives companies two years. Yours said one.
Does that matter? Both chambers passed it.
They passed different texts. The President can only sign a bill both chambers passed word for word.
So we vote again??
Predict, then reveal
You're Maya, and Brooks asks what to do next. Insist on one year and go to a conference committee, or accept the Senate's two years?
For the first time, both chambers have passed the same words. The final text is printed on parchment and signed by the Speaker. For the Senate, it's signed by the Vice President or the president pro tempore. Then it's sent to the White House.
Worth keeping
- The House limits debate with a rule, while the Senate needs unanimous agreement or cloture.
- Cloture ends debate with three-fifths of all senators, usually 60.
- After cloture, the bill passes with a simple majority of those voting.
- Both chambers must pass the exact same text before it goes to the President.
The bill lands at the White House on a Thursday. Then nothing happens. No signing, no veto, no statement. Brooks tells Maya that silence has a result too, and it depends on whether Congress is still in session.